Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


A Horrible Tragedy but a Golden Opportunity

by Ravi Pandey

January 3, 2006

Readers Write

 

For a buffalo which cannot be more than 5000 Rs (120 $) 6 human beings were killed. Burnt alive. Nobody came to their rescue. A horrible tragedy, so horrible that parallel, if any, can only be found in Bihar. Shame and disgrace is felt by everyone, every Bihari, once again.

But the worst is yet to come. This horrible incident will be forgotten by all too soon. It may be revenged by another equally horrible incident. A shame and disgrace will be repeated again. The culprits will either go Scot free or will spend few years in jail and will come out either as politicians or as more hardcore criminals.

Life of poor, extremely poor of my brothers and sister cannot be brought back. But Nitish Kumar government has a golden opportunity. Justice can be done. Culprits can be put behind bars for life. Let's put culprits behind bar. Let us do a open trial in public Let the culprit get death sentence by court. Let him fight for mercy court after court. Let them feel what they have done . Give them time in solitary confinement to realize what they have done. Let people of whole India and world know that Jungle Raj no longer exist in Bihar.

Can we all Bihari take a resolution that like Satyendra Dubey we are not going to forget these poor people's sacrifice also. Can we check with local government official about progress of case. Can we ask for CBI inquiry. Can we ask for trial outside local area or outside even Bihar. Can we raise some fund for whatever left of poor family.

I am requesting members of PatnaDaily forum to draft a letter to Hon Nitish Kumar and we all will put electronic signature and send it my postal mail. This is a time to do something. We can not keep talking and blaming someone.

Comments:
Wow!!! The first empathetic words on the plight for the poor Mahto family come from a Mr. Pandey! I thought that the great pursuers of social justice who raised such a ruckus recently on the caste issue, would have been the first on this! But then, how could they? The perpetrators are "Rai's" and the victims were "Mahto's". So, is it okay to keep quiet on a dastardly crime like that? If the perpetrators were Mishras or Sharmas or Pandeys, then you should have seen the 'tandav' of the bigoted bunch!

Also, No points to Mr. Pandey for referring to the victims as his "brothers and sisters"! Why do the people who engage in casteist 'narebaazi', not speak up on an issue like this ?! Where is their sentiment and 'bhaichara'?

Their silence on such and issue is as ugly as their whiny/abusive speech at other times.

I am curious to see what action those hands, that went limp on the Narendra Singh issue, will take on this one - especially since this type of crime has come to symbolize Bihar internationally. - Aarcee - Jan. 4, 2006

I'm an Italian writer based in Thailand and I was deeply impressed by the story of the poor family killed for a buffalo. I fully appreciate your comment and I would like to visit Bihar and contact some of you. I have never been in Bihar but I know that is not all like this story showing. I hope am not bothering you with this request of meeting, but I really appreciate any sign by your side. - Raimondo Bultrini - Jan. 5, 2006


Hi Raimondo, thanks for your comment and feeling. I hope you are a genuine writer who wants to know the real evil and want to do something to eradicate such rogue. I hope you are not the kind of author who sells poverty and evil as spice in western countries . We have plenty of those in India.

Now unfortunately most of the people whose comments and story you read are NRI (Non Resident Indians). So to meet them you will have to go to USA or UK or may be you can meet some in Bangkok.

I am in USA please let me know if you are coming this way. - Ravi Pandey - Jan. 6, 2006


Mr. Bultrini, If you want to visit Bihar because some people killed a family for a buffalo, then you are being naive. Such dastardly acts are going on everywhere in the world. This pales in comparison to many other ongoing conflicts that people like you should be looking at. This is merely an isolated criminal act.

I suggest you go to the occupied territories (Gaza Strip & West Bank) and see how brutal man is to man for a sliver of land. Go see how deep the hatred is and how involved the rest of the world is in that 'pettiness'. After a life time at each other's throats, the arch enemies Arafat and Sharon (maybe) are dead. Thousands have been killed over the control of Jerusalem. Go research why Homo Sapiens (man) wears colors of religion to annihilate one another.

Most Journalists go to Bihar, take the worst pictures and publish it in magazines that have an agenda to portray India in a bad light. Before you go to India, read Kevin Rushby's novel "Children of Kali" and decide if you are learned enough yet to be able to understand what you will see there. I can go to Italy and all kinds of pasta will look the same to me. So, give your impulsive decision some thought. India can not be examined by an outsider in a "two week whirlwind tour". It requires research, a will of iron and the ability to mingle with the common man in the sweltering heat of the crowded cities and villages for months on end to get anywhere near a true understanding (if there is any) of India. - Aarcee - Jan. 6, 2006

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2004, PatnaDaily.Com.