Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


Nearer the Church, Farther From the God

by Bhaskaranand Jha
Kolkata

May 12, 2006

Readers Write

 

In the last two-three decades, Bihar, once a well known seat of learning and cultures attracting the people of the world towards its varied richness in various fields, has earned for it a dark and bad name more because of, say, the nefarious deeds of its people earning their livelihood in other states, the economic backwardness, caste-based cruel politics and inactiveness of its people. All these factors have led to inferiority complex in Biharis. What a shame that even a few gentlemen (Biharis) shy of calling themselves Biharis in a talk with so-called educated people of other states.

While living in West Bengal for more than three years what I have observed very closely is that unlike Biharis, the people of other states feel very proud of being the people of their respective states. They never complain to anyone against anything pertaining to their states. What is more, they rather highlight their qualitative features everywhere they live. But we Biharis often talk ill of Bihar so much so that we sometimes hide the fact that we are Biharis. We are often led by inferiority complex. I think that Bihar is defamed more because of our own ill-propagation than all other social, political, economical evils and all other ills gripping Bihar ruthlessly. We should understand that let alone states, everyman is a mixture of good and bad. But what we should do is highlight our goodness and hide our evils. When we do this, goodness is sure to dominate evils, which in due course will no longer be in practice.

In short, let us all Biharis take a strong and determined vow that from now onwards we won’t express our grumbling at anything of Bihar. Nor do we make any complaint to ‘outsiders’ against its social, political and economical problems, which are common more or less in almost all the states of India. On the other hand, we must cultivate the habit of highlighting various qualities, past glory of Bihar. At the same time we should develop civic sense, sense of responsibility and positive attitude towards our state and try to individually give contribution in any way to the all-round prosperity of Bihar. Like the citizens of other developed and developing states, we should dispel the sense of discrimination between he-child and she-child, and be satisfied only with one child whether girl or boy. We should ensure the child’s proper education. We should never resort to the feeling of casteism amongst us, never practice caste-based politics.

Last but not the least, let’s all proclaim with pride that we are the brave sons of Bihar which has given light to others, even to the foreign countries at the cost of darkness in its own home. We have always been giver to the world. We are not the people to be pitied on. Let’s dive into the past glory and bring back the fragments of honour for the sake of our mother state.

 

Comments:
Well, I don’t agree with what Bhaskaranand Jha has stated in his article (Nearer The Church Farther The God). Just by disclosing the qualities and past glory of Bihar in other states, do you think that the condition of Bihar will change dramatically? Unless and until the Govt. is active towards the development of Bihar nothing is going to change and mere shouting about the qualities of Bihar is useless as everyone knows what is Bihar right now. So let's hope the best from the present Govt. in Bihar and this effort is only going to make Biharis proud. - Priyanka Sandhwar - May 13, 2006

Even in theory, I am not sure how much will actually be accomplished by the "fake it until you make it" school of thought. If it works that way, then after your death we will build your statue right over the middle of the Ganges river. In fact, I think it will be far more damaging to Bihar than our current insistence to point out what is wrong here. If, God forbid, we ever have communal Violence, let's all say we had a friendly match and we are celebrating Holi. Implementing your ideas, Bihar will have overnight development and we can not only compare Bihar to USA or Japan, but we will have surpassed them, and we will shoot directly to Mars or Pluto. To play this kind of game with words and images will do nothing to enhance the development of Bihar. To ignore the accountability of our ministers and elected officials only adds to the problems.

There is nothing wrong with embracing the good things in our state: past and present. There is no detriment to having dreams of a brighter future for our people and our state. These things are necessary to forming a vision for the development of Bihar, but they are not the only requirements. In order to formulate a plan and execute it completely, we need to know the reality of the situation as it is presently, and the changes we want to see. Acknowledgement is key in any undertaking of this nature. Good intentions and fanciful thinking have been around forever, but they only work miraculously in stories intended for children. Real life demands a solid base of reality from which to work. Positive movement requires planning, work and sacrifice. - S. M. Khurshid Anwar, New York, USA - May 14, 2006


In his article, writer has behaved like Laloo Prasad Yadavji, who used to say the same things when delivering speech in rallies. I have just one question, suppose we go to other states with our heads high (even with weak shoulders, crumbling) and stand in front of people from other states and start yelling 'We are proud of being Bihari'. If somebody asks, 'For what you are proud of ..?', we would say 'we are proud of roads, crime, electricity, politics, jobs...' and we can easily see our head coming down and bending our shoulders.

To be proud requires something to support the neck so that the head could stand still. We can always curse media and politicians for defaming Biharis but that is not going to bring self-confidence to Biharis. Something has to be done to strengthen the economic and social condition of Bihar, so that people of other states start coming to us for jobs. This move may change the attitude of Non-Biharis towards Biharis. When they earn here, and go back to their native, safe and secure, they would definitely sing the praises of our native land and things would change drastically. What about starting IT industry there??? - Ravish Kumar, Hyderabad - May 15, 2006

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2006, PatnaDaily.Com.