Home |Contact Us | Site Map

 

Readers Write Index

 


Nalanda University Revival and Real Politics

by T. V. Sinha

June 25, 2007

Readers Write

 

Please read this article:

I find it in extremely poor taste. The idea of revival of the Nalanda University was propounded by President Kalam and enthusiastically supported by Nitish Kumar. In a remarkable show of pan global view, Sushil Modi, the Dy CM of Bihar announced the name of Prof Amartya Sen as Chairman of the proposed Nalanda University. An ancient institution to be re-built with the help of several nations including China is first sought to be reduced to a tool of real politik in the hands of Pranab Mukherjee. Then Shilbhadra is projected as a Bengali!!

Did Bengal or Bengali language even exist in the sixth - seventh century when Shilbhadra was the abbot of Nalanda? Mr Santosh Pandey, a Chartered Accountant from Bihar, Chapra, presently living in Sarajevo in Bosnia & Herzegovina and working with ArcelorMittal Group and someone we interact with each other on several matters related to Bihar, did detailed Google search and informed us that old Bengali started to form as a language only after 900 AD from Prakrit Magadhi via Ardh Magadhi. Middle Bengali formed after 1400 AD and modern Bengali from late 18th century. British grammarian Nathaniel Brassey Halhed codified Bengali grammar - A Grammar of the Bengal Language only in 1778. Indrani Bagchi might as well claim that son is born before his father!!!

In a naked display of regional chauvinism, there is not even a mention of the 500 acres of land that the govt of Bihar is acquiring for the university. Bear in mind that Chinese Govt has constructed a marvelous memorial at Nalanda for Xuan Zang (Hsiuen Tsang), the famous Chinese traveler whose writings helped identify its long forgotten location and the excavation of Nalanda University was started. I would not be surprised if Chinese Govt also contributes to the Rs 1,000 cr kitty being created for Nalanda University and plays an important role in this international endeavor.

Let us protest strongly against chauvinism of any kind being sought to be introduced in this noble cause. Let us leave at least a few things like our ancient heritage of Nalanda University alone for overall betterment of humanity than put real politics into everything.
 

Comments:
A few days back I wrote one article on our decision making ability and the way our Government is moving in this issue, the so called PHILOSOPHICAL Nalanda International University and more or less many issues.

Let us first resurrect our dying universities and their system, culture, morality and ethics of education and the meaning of higher education. Let us start research oriented Master program in at least one, Patna University. Let us transude our own intellectual capability in the field of art, science and culture.

We can achieve this "only" after reversing the persistent present-trend in our university campuses. And we can become trend-setter. And generation-next will establish this ruined university with great pride and with no dearth of good intellectuals, visionary and futuristic mindset. And certainly they will revive "NALANDA UNIVERSITY". Not the one we are begging for. No place on this earth can develop themselves without igniting passion for/of local pride. Let Biharis/Nalanda'ites be ready for reconstruction.

THINK BIG!!! THINK AHEAD!!!! DON'T BEG!!!! HOLD INTELLECTS!!!! - Dr. Sudhir Ranjan, USA - June 25, 2007

I agree with Mr. T. V. Sinha's comments. In fact Historians also believe Shilbhadra was from a place near Silao - the place near ancient Nalanda University and famous for its Khaja. So Indrani Bagchi is wrong on two counts

1. Stating that it was Pranab Mukherji's initiative
2. Shilbhdra was a Bengali

For god's sake get over this Bengali Phobia. This kind of approach is sickening. - Naveen K. Sharma - June 25, 2007


India is seriously suffering from "State Subnationalism". It is more prevalent in some states, Bengal being one of them.

Unfortunately national leaders also fall prey to this as they are also product of same social background. I hope an international personality like Amartya Sen will not fall prey to same sentiments.

Bihar and Orissa were part of Bengal presidency during British . From that aspect every Bihari during those days could be called a Bengali. I wonder why they have not so far claimed (Late) Dr Rajendra Prasad as Bengali. People in other states of India want to recognize as Bihari only those people who work as labor, milkman, washerman, vegetable sellers & domestic servants in Metro cities of India. They dont recognize the vast number of Great People born in Bihar like Ashoka, Chandragupta, Kautilya, Mahavira, Democracy of Vaishali, Shershah, Veer Kunwar Singh in the past and Dr Rajendra Prasad, Jai Prakash Narain, large number of intelligent people going to Delhi University, IITs & NIITs, IAS & Allied Officers & the courage of Danapur Regiment during Chinese war in present days.

BIHAR Govt needs to do something about it thru a media blast. Gujarat Govt ran a "VIBRANT GUJARAT" campaign even in USA. Bihar should promote the state at least as tourist destination with its glorious past. Patna should have a Light & Sound effect program on its history at a place beautified on the banks of the Ganges. Govt should also organize a Bihar festival at Delhi, Mumbai and Chennai to promote tourism & familiarize people of other parts of India with its culture with good media coverage. Government owes this to its people. - Mithilesh Kumar, Delmar, New York, USA - June 25, 2007


I am equally concerned but Bihar must get its respectability back. Nitish is doing a fine work. Unfortunately, not many of his ministers are up to the mark. He could have persuaded the alliance and taken some unelected technocrats in his cabinet. Bihar must develop some of its soft power. We must create splashes in India by completing the projects in time. The state government must help in executing all the central projects such as GQ and East-West corridor of expressways going through the state. It must get AIIMS and IIT started as soon as possible. - Indra - June 28, 2007


I am very much for the revival of Nalanda University. But the past glory cannot be revived if any kind of politics is played. We have to think several times whether we deserve and whether we can sustain such a revival despite spectacular achievements of our IITs and IIMs. Nalanda had a very different set up with concentration on various schools of logics and philosophies. Only thirty percent of all scholars, who wanted entry into the university, could succeed in securing admission. Such foreign scholars, who even falsely declared in their home countries that they had studied at Nalanda, were honored by their respective governments.

The point of discussion should not be whether Sheelbhadra was a Bengali or not, rather who should be the right person to be the chancellor of the revived Nalanda University as also what should be its curriculum and why?

There is no harm in accepting cooperation from and collaboration of foreign countries. It does not amount to begging. It is not that India cannot afford to set up Nalanda University but it should be done in order to highlight the fact that other countries had also benefited from the oldest university of the world. And they owe a lot to it. After all it has to achieve its global character and glory. All, who have benefited from it directly or indirectly, must unite and contribute. - Narendra K. Sinha, Ph.D., Alumni of Nalanda Pali Institute - June 28, 2007

Discussion on this topic is now closed.

Return to previous Page

 

 

All rights reserved, 2000-2006, PatnaDaily.Com.